Drivers of Inequality in Millennium Development Goal Progress: A Statistical Analysis

English version České info

Background:
Many low- and middle-income countries are not on track to reach the public health targets set out in the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs). We evaluated whether differential progress towards health MDGs was associated with economic development, public health funding (both overall and as percentage of available domestic funds), or health system infrastructure. We also examined the impact of joint epidemics of HIV/AIDS and noncommunicable diseases (NCDs), which may limit the ability of households to address child mortality and increase risks of infectious diseases.

Methods and Findings:
We calculated each country's distance from its MDG goals for HIV/AIDS, tuberculosis, and infant and child mortality targets for the year 2005 using the United Nations MDG database for 227 countries from 1990 to the present. We studied the association of economic development (gross domestic product [GDP] per capita in purchasing-power-parity), the relative priority placed on health (health spending as a percentage of GDP), real health spending (health system expenditures in purchasing-power-parity), HIV/AIDS burden (prevalence rates among ages 15–49 y), and NCD burden (age-standardised chronic disease mortality rates), with measures of distance from attainment of health MDGs. To avoid spurious correlations that may exist simply because countries with high disease burdens would be expected to have low MDG progress, and to adjust for potential confounding arising from differences in countries' initial disease burdens, we analysed the variations in rates of change in MDG progress versus expected rates for each country. While economic development, health priority, health spending, and health infrastructure did not explain more than one-fifth of the differences in progress to health MDGs among countries, burdens of HIV and NCDs explained more than half of between-country inequalities in child mortality progress (R²-infant mortality = 0.57, R²-under 5 mortality = 0.54). HIV/AIDS and NCD burdens were also the strongest correlates of unequal progress towards tuberculosis goals (R² = 0.57), with NCDs having an effect independent of HIV/AIDS, consistent with micro-level studies of the influence of tobacco and diabetes on tuberculosis risks. Even after correcting for health system variables, initial child mortality, and tuberculosis diseases, we found that lower burdens of HIV/AIDS and NCDs were associated with much greater progress towards attainment of child mortality and tuberculosis MDGs than were gains in GDP. An estimated 1% lower HIV prevalence or 10% lower mortality rate from NCDs would have a similar impact on progress towards the tuberculosis MDG as an 80% or greater rise in GDP, corresponding to at least a decade of economic growth in low-income countries.

Conclusions:
Unequal progress in health MDGs in low-income countries appears significantly related to burdens of HIV and NCDs in a population, after correcting for potentially confounding socioeconomic, disease burden, political, and health system variables. The common separation between NCDs, child mortality, and infectious syndromes among development programs may obscure interrelationships of illness affecting those living in poor households—whether economic (e.g., as money spent on tobacco is lost from child health expenditures) or biological (e.g., as diabetes or HIV enhance the risk of tuberculosis).

: Please see later in the article for the Editors' Summary

Vyšlo v časopise: Drivers of Inequality in Millennium Development Goal Progress: A Statistical Analysis. PLoS Med 7(3): e32767. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1000241
Kategorie: Research Article
prolekare.web.journal.doi_sk: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1000241

Souhrn

Zdroje

1. WHO 2008 Monitoring achievement of the health-related Millennium Development Goals; WHO, editor. Geneva. Available: http://www.who.int/gb/ebwha/pdf_files/A61/A61_15-en.pdf. Accessed: 15 March 2009

2. Gil-GonzalezD

Ruiz-CanteroMT

Alvarez-DardetC

2009 How political epidemiology research can address why the millennium development goals have not been achieved: developing a research agenda. J Epidemiol Community Health 63 278 280

3. AtunR

LebcirRM

McKeeM

HabichtJ

CokerRJ

2007 Impact of joined-up HIV harm reduction and multidrug resistant tuberculosis control programmes in Estonia: System dynamics simulation model. Health Policy 81 207 217

4. UNAIDS 2007 World Health Organization. AIDS epidemic update. Geneva: UNAIDS. Available: http://data.unaids.org/pub/EPISlides/2007/2007_epiupdate_en.pdf

5. AlbanA

AndersenNB

2007 HIV/AIDS' spread and impact on other health-related millennium development goals–secondary publication. Dan Med Bull 54 163 166

6. CorbettE

WattCJ

WalkerN

MaherD

2003 The growing burden of tuberculosis: global trends and interactions with the HIV epidemic. Arch Intern Med 163 1009 1021

7. DyeC

WattCJ

BleedDM

HosseiniSM

RaviglioneMC

2005 Evolution of tuberculosis control and prospecdts for reducing tuberculosis incidence, prevalence and deaths globally. JAMA 293 2767 2775

8. DaarA

SingerPA

PersadDL

PrammingSK

MatthewsDR

2007 Grand challenges in chronic non-communicable diseases. Nature 450 494 496

9. RileyL

KoAI

UngerA

ReisMG

2007 Slum health: diseases of neglected populations. BMC Int Health Hum Rights 7

10. World Bank 1999 Global Trends in Tobacco Use. Curbing the epidemic: Governments and the Economics of Tobacco Control Washington (D.C.) World Bank

11. JhaP

JacobB

GajalakshmiV

GuptaPC

DhingraN

2008 A nationally representative case-control study of smoking and death in India. N Engl J Med 358 1137 1147

12. MajraJ

GurA

2009 Poverty, tobacco, and health: an Indian scenario. J Health Popul Nutr 27 316 318

13. SuhrckeM

NugentR

StucklerD

2006 Chronic disease: An economic perspective. London Oxford Health Alliance

14. StucklerD

2008 Population causes and consequences of leading chronic diseases: A comparative analysis of prevailing explanations. Milbank Q 86 273 326

15. PopkinB

2002 What is unique about the experience in lower- and middle-income less-industrialised countries comparied with the very-high income countries?The shift in the stages of the nutrition transition differs from past experiences! Public Health Nutr 5 205 214

16. YachD

StucklerD

BrownellK

2006 Epidemiologic and economic consequences of the global epidemics of obesity and diabetes. Nat Med 12 62 66

17. HawkesC

2006 Uneven dietary development: linking the policies and processes of globalisation with the nutrition transition, obesity and diet-related chronic diseases. Global Health 2

18. RaynerG

HawkesC

LangT

BelloW

2005 Trade liberalisation and the diet and nutrition transition: a public health response. Department of Health Management & Food Policy, CITY University, London.

19. PopkinB

RichardsMK

MontieroCA

1996 Stunting is associated with overweight in children of four nations that are undergoing nutrition transition. Am J Nutr 126 3009 3016

20. DoakC

AdairLS

MonteiroC

PopkinBM

2000 Overweight and underweight coexist within households in Brazil, China and Russia. J Nutr 130

21. FlorencioT

FerreiraH

de FrancaAP

CavalcanteJC

SawyaAL

2001 Obesity and undernutrition in a very-low-income population in the city of Maceio, northeastern Brazil. Br J Nutr 86

22. LonnrothK

JaramilloE

WilliamsBG

DyeC

RaviglioneM

2009 Drivers of tuberculosis epidemics: the role of risk factors and social determinants. Soc Sci Med 68 2240 2246

23. StevensonC

ForouhiNF

RoglicG

WilliamsBG

LauerJA

2007 Diabetes and tuberculosis: The impact of the diabetes epidemic on tuberculosis incidence. BMC Public Health 7 234

24. Ponce-De-LeonA

Garcia-Garcia Md MdeL

Garcia-SanchoMC

Gomez-PerezFJ

Valdespino-GomezJL

2004 Tuberculosis and diabetes in southern Mexico. Diabetes Care 27 1047 1053

25. GajalakshmiV

PetoR

KanakaT

JhaP

2003 Smoking and mortality from tuberculosis and other diseases in India: retrospective study of 43000 adult male deaths and 35000 controls. Lancet 16 507 515

26. EfroymsonD

AhmedS

TownsendJ

AlamSM

DeyAR

2001 Hungry for tobacco: an analysis of the economic impact of tobacco consumption on the poor in Bangladesh. Tob Control 10 212 217

27. NonnemakerJ

SurM

2007 Tobacco expenditures and child health and nutritional outcomes in rural Bangladesh. Soc Sci Med 65 2517 2526

28. ShobhanaR

RaoPR

LavanyaA

WilliamsR

VijayV

2000 Expenditure on healthcare incurred by diabetic subjects in a developing country - a study from Southern India. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 48 37 42

29. NeuhannH

Warter-NeuhannC

LyaruuI

MsuyaL

2002 Diabetes care in Kilimajaro region: clinical presentation and problems of patients of the diabetes clinic at the regional referral hospital - an inventory before structured intervention. Diabetes Med 19 509 513

30. KibriyaM

AliL

BanikNG

Azad KhanAK

1999 Home monitoring of blood glucose (HMBG) in Type 2 diabetes mellitus in a developing country. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 46 253 257

31. BarceloA

AedoC

RajpathakS

RoblesS

2003 The cost of diabetes in Latin America and the Caribbean. Bull WHO 81 19 27

32. LeartsakulpanitchJ

NganthaveeW

SaloleE

2007 The economic burden of smoking-related disease in Thailand: a prevalence-based analysis. J Med Assoc Thai 90 1925 1929

33. SuT

KouyateB

FlessaS

2006 Catastrophic household expenditure for health care in a low-income society: a study from Nouna District, Burkina Faso. Bull WHO 84 21 27

34. SomkotraT

LagradaLP

2009 Which households are at risk of catastrophic health spending: experience in Thailand after universal coverage. Health Affairs 28 w467 468

35. GoudgeJ

GilsonL

RussellS

GumedeT

MillsA

2009 Affordability, availability and acceptability barriers to healthcare for the chronically ill: Longitudinal case studies from South Africa. BMC Health Serv Res 9 75

36. DrorD

van Putten-RademakerO

KorenR

2008 Cost of illness: evidence from a study in five resource-poor locations in India. Indian J Med Res 127 347 361

37. CawleyJ

2000 Body weight and women's labor market outcomes. NBER Working Paper No 7841. Cambridge (Massachusetts)

38. CawleyJ

2004 The impact of obesity on wages. Journal of Human Resources 32 451 474

39. CawleyJ

DanzigerS

2004 Obesity as a barrier to the transition from welfare to work. NBER Working Paper No 10508

40. DwyerD

MitchellOS

1999 Health problems as determinants of retirement: are self-rated measures endogenous. J Health Econ 18

41. FinkelsteinE

RuhmCJ

KosaKM

2005 Economic causes and consequences of obesity. Annu Rev Public Health 26 239 257

42. McGillavrayM

2008 Achieving the Millennium Development Goals. London Palgrave

43. SsewanyanaS

YoungerSD

2008 Infant mortality in Uganda: Determinants, trends and the Millennium Development Goals. J African Econ 17 34 61

44. United Nations 2008 Millennium Development Goal Indicator Database. UN.

45. GrahamW

BrassW

SnowRW

1989 Estimating maternal mortality: the sisterhood method. Stud Fam Plann 20 125 135

46. UNICEF 1999 Roll back malaria, The Global Fund. Malaria & children: Progress in intervention coverage. New York UNICEF

47. World Bank 1993 Investing in Health. Washington D.C. World Bank

48. World Health Organization 2009 Statistical Information System (WHOSIS). World Health Organization Geneva Available: http://www.who.int/whosis/whostat/EN_WHS09_Tables.xls

49. World Health Organization 2009 Mortality and burden of disease estimates for WHO Member States in 2004. Geneva World Health Organization Available: http://www.who.int/healthinfo/global_burden_disease/2004_report_update/en/index.html; http://www.who.int/whosis/whostat/EN_WHS09_Table2.pdf. Accessed 15 March 2009

50. AhmadO

Boschi-PintoC

LopezAD

MurrayCJL

LozanoR

2001 Age standardization of rates: a new WHO standard. Geneva: World Health Organisation. Available: http://www.who.int/healthinfo/paper31.pdf. Accessed 19 December 2009

51. GlynnJ

WarndorffDK

FinePE

MunthaliMM

SichoneW

PonnighausJM

1998 Measurement and determinants of tuberculosis outcome in Karonga District, Malawi. Bull WHO 76 295 305

52. KorenrompE

BierrenbachAL

WilliamsBG

DyeC

2009 The measurement and estimation of tuberculosis mortality. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 13 283 303

53. FosterG

Williamson

2000 A review of current literature on the impact of HIV/AIDS on children in sub-Saharan Africa. AIDS 14 S275 284

54. WHO 2006 Diagnostics for tuberculosis: global demand and market potential. Geneva World Health Organization

55. WHO 2005 Preventing Chronic Diseases: A Vital Investment. WHO, editor. Geneva

56. WHO 2004 Global Burden of Disease Surveillance. World Health Organization

57. World Health Organization 2008 The World Health Report 2008 - primary Health Care. Geneva WHO

58. ClaytonT

ThompsonM

MeadeTW

2008 Recent respiratory infection and risk of cardiovascular disease: case-control study through a general practice database. Eur Heart J 29 96 103

59. MituschR

LuedemannJ

WoodWG

BergerK

SchminkeU

2005 Asymptomatic carotid atherosclerosis is associated with circulating Chlamydia pneumoniae DNA in younger normotensive subjects in a general population. Arterioscle Thromb Vasc Bio 25 386 391

60. RichardsonS

WillcoxA

BoneAJ

FoulisAK

MorganNG

2009 The prevalence of enteroviral capsid protein vp1 immunostaining in pancreatic islets in human type 1 diabetes. Diabeteologia 52 1143 1151

61. ReidpathD

MorelCM

MecaskeyJW

AlloteyP

2009 The Millennium Development Goals fail poor children: The case for equity-adjusted measures. PLoS Med 6 e1000062

62. NaimoliJ

2009 Global health partnerships in practice: taking stock of the GAVI Alliance's new investment in health systems strengthening. Int J Health Plan Mgmt 24 3 25

63. YuD

SouteyrandY

BandaMA

KaufmanJ

PerriensJH

2008 Investment in HIV/AIDS programs: Does it help strengthen health systems in developing countries? Global Health 4

64. KramerM

1987 Determinants of low birthweight, methodological assessment & meta-analysis. Bull WHO 65 663 733

65. JohnR

2008 Crowding out effect of tobacco expenditure and its implications on household resource allocation in India. Soc Sci Med 66 1356 1367

66. DiFranzaJ

LewRA

1995 Effect of maternal cigarette smoking on pregnancy complications and sudden infant death syndrome. J Fam Pract 40 385 394

67. JeonC

MurrayMB

2008 Diabetes mellitus increases the risk of active tuberculosis: a systematic review of 13 observational studies. PLoS Med 5 e152 doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0050152